Should I be using paid ads or focusing on organic growth?

You’re trying to grow but you have limited time, a limited budget, and everyone seems to have a different opinion about what you should be doing.

Some say: “You have to run ads if you want results.”
Others say: “You shouldn’t ever have to run ads if you’re doing organic right.”

So what’s actually true?

At Mettle Marketing Co., we’ve worked with many businesses at every stage - from early solopreneurs to established brands - and here’s what we’ve learned:

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But there is a right mix for your specific season and goals.

This blog post will help you cut through the noise by showing you:

  • The difference between paid and organic marketing

  • When each one makes the most sense

  • And how the best strategies often blend both

Paid vs. Organic Marketing: A Quick Comparison

So What’s Right for You? Let’s Break It Down

If you need fast results…

Go with paid ads. They’re like turning on a faucet.
Especially helpful if:

  • You’re launching a new offer or event

  • You need to drive traffic now

  • You’re validating an idea

BUT: paid results disappear when the budget stops, so plan for what comes next (email marketing? organic marketing? something else?)

If you want long-term brand trust…

Lean into organic marketing.
This includes content like:

  • Blogs (like this one!)

  • Email newsletters

  • Social media posts

  • SEO-optimized website content

Organic builds a foundation that keeps working long after it’s posted.

If your budget is limited…

Start with organic. ESPECIALLY if you have more time than money!

But if your time is also limited (hello fellow business owners!), try:

  • Focusing on 1-2 platforms only

  • Repurposing content (blog posts turned into newsletters turned into social media content)

  • Using a small, strategic ad spend to amplify your best organic content (it’s amazing what a well-used $3 a day will do!)

If you’re overwhelmed by the algorithm…

Ads can cut through the noise.
They let you reach exactly who you want without hoping the algorithm favors you.

BUT: they still need strategy. Bad ads = wasted money. Trust us.

The Best Strategies Often Combine Both

Think of it like this:

Paid ads are like fuel, they get things moving.
Organic content is like the engine, it keeps your momentum going.

Here’s how they work together:

  • Paid ads drive new eyes to your content

  • Organic content builds trust once they land on your site or feed

  • The two together shorten the buyer journey and increase conversions

When your marketing is working well, paid and organic don’t compete, they complement each other.

Final Thought: Choose Based on Strategy, Not Trends

You don’t have to be everywhere (in fact, we recommend you AREN’T everywhere). You don’t have to do everything. But you DO need a clear plan that fits your goals, your season, and your audience.

If you’re not sure where to start, or how to build a strategy that blends both paid and organic marketing effectively, we’d love to help.

We just recently helped one of our clients increase the number of lead generators downloaded on their website by 540% in the first month by re-evaluating the strategy they were using with paid and organic marketing (and we didn’t increase their budget at all)!

Book a free discovery call and let’s figure out what makes sense for you.

FAQ

Q: What’s considered “organic” marketing?
Anything you don’t directly pay to boost—like blog content, SEO, social media posts, and email marketing.

Q: What’s a good budget for paid ads?
It varies! Many small businesses start around $300–$500/month (but we’ve seen strong results with budgets as small as $150 per month). The key is strategic targeting and testing, not just spending more.

Q: Can I grow my business using just organic marketing?
Yes—but it typically takes more time and consistency. If you need quick visibility or lead flow, pairing with paid ads is often ideal.

Next
Next

Why isn’t my current marketing strategy bringing in leads?

Mettle Marketing Co.

Questions?

Contact us

Feature Paid Ads Organic Marketing
Speed Fast—results can start within days Slower—momentum builds over time
Cost Requires ongoing investment Low/no cost, but time-intensive
Longevity Stops when budget stops Long-lasting (SEO, evergreen content)
Trust-building Can feel interruptive or “salesy” if not done right Builds credibility and connection over time
Best for Testing offers, quick visibility, launches Brand building, lead nurturing, long-term growth